Issue link: http://viewer.e-digitaledition.com/i/589857
EXPERT ADVICE MD NEWS ASKED three hospital security insiders to share their top tips for increasing security at healthcare facilities. Joseph A. Hendry Jr., CLEE, Lieutenant with the Kent State University Police Department in Ohio: "Having armed security is good. Ensuring those people are trained is even better. Lots of security [personnel] carry a gun and that's about it; they don't receive a lot of training. "The medical staff needs to go through training and then apply those concepts to where they work in the hospital: 'Which rooms are appropriate for lockdown? What do we have to barricade with? How do we evacuate if we can?' You will get more bang for your buck from training your employees than you ever will from physical security." Darren Morgan, Corporate Director of Patient Transport, Safety and Security at Citrus Valley Health Partners in Glendora, California: "Partnering with law enforcement [is important]. At each of our campuses, we have great working relationships with law enforcement, and on a regular basis have police departments participate in staff training and conduct their own SWAT training in unused areas of the campuses. That provides them with access to and familiarity with our campuses. "Most important for us is to train everyone. We've trained physicians and staff members on how to respond to an active shooter situation, and then we've drilled it." Ben Scaglione, CPP, CHPA, CHSP, Director of Healthcare Security Services at Florida- based G4S Secure Solutions, Inc.: "Clinical staff generally are [active shooters'] targets. … They're the ones who are most likely to be able to identify individuals who could be a problem. "From a security perspective, clinical staff are [often] very hesitant about [pointing out potential threats]. They should be more willing to work with security, legal and administration when they feel someone may be a potential shooter. Individuals who become active shoot- ers have a lot of behavioral health issues, and we need to be better as healthcare institutions at identifying and treating them." Hospitals face unique challenges in responding to active shooters, including the facilities' size, layout, relative open- ness vis-à-vis security, disparate health and mobility statuses of patients, and staff training. The "run, hide, fight" strategy translates well to the hospital environment, experts say, as long as healthcare leaders and providers view it through the lens of adaptability. Run If a hospita l issues a n a lert that an active shooter is on its campus, evacuation to a predetermined rally point — preferably severa l build- ings away — should be the default response for all individuals who are able to flee without crossing the path of the assailant. "Evacuation, in any crisis, has always b een hu ma ns' pr ima r y resp onse, except for active shooter events, for which we've glommed on to lock- down — which is antithetical [to our instincts]," says Joseph A. Hendry Jr., CLEE, Lieutenant with the Kent State University Police Department in Ohio and a frequent speaker and trainer on the subject of active shooter response. "It is important to identif y through training who can evacuate, who can't, what the evacuation points are and where to go if evacuation is possible. Emptying large sections of the building helps law enforcement by reducing angst when they secure those areas. I haven't encountered an incident yet, other than the Jonesboro, Arkansas, school shooting in 1998, in which evacuating a facility resulted in death." Evacuation is not a n option for non-ambulator y patients and their ca regivers a nd may not be practi- cal for someone in close proximity to the shooter's location. For these individuals, localized lockdown and secure sheltering in place is the best response, experts say. Hide The efficacy of lockdow n hinges on the environment. An ideal lock- down location features sturdy doors, few windows — particularly those close to doors — and plenty of materials to bar- ricade doors, which often can't be locked in hospitals. Chairs and rolling carts are excellent items for creating a barricade. "If staff are unable to evacuate with their patients, we instruct them to block the doors leading into their room or unit, to get anything that will move into the path of the aggressor," says Darren Morgan, Corporate Director of Patient Transport, Safety and Security at Citrus Valley Health Partners, a four-facility system in California's San Gabriel Valley. "We want our staff to protect themselves fi rst because a provider who can't protect him- or herself can't help anyone." Fight Distracting an attacker with noise or movement is an appropriate response to an active shooter if one's life or the lives of oth- ers are in imminent danger — for example, if an attacker breaches a barricaded room and no avenue of evacuation exists. "We want hospital personnel to be able to protect themselves if need be," says Ben Scaglione, CPP, CHPA, CHSP, Director of Healthcare Security Services at G4S Secure Solutions, Inc., a Florida-based security company serving the United States and Canada. "Using the fi re extinguisher to hit or spray an assailant is very effective; it wouldn't be wise to do in a corridor but [would be advisable] if you're cornered." Plan Flexibly The most effective active shooter response plan is one tailored to your hos- pital's strengths and limitations. "Lots of times, we worry about doing A, B, C and D for a policy, but in reality, plans need to be fl exible based on location and circumstances," Lt. Hendry says. "'Run, fi ght, hide' isn't a linear solution." ■ 2 0 1 5 N OV E M B E R / D E C E M B E R ■ M D N E W S . CO M ■ MD NEWS Cleveland/Akron/Canton | 2 9

