Team Insight

January / February 2019

Issue link: https://viewer.e-digitaledition.com/i/1075743

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 18 of 60

The Flap Around C-Flap The issue of the legality of the C-Flap, the now ubiquitous protective attachment for batting helmets from Markwort Sporting Goods, shows no sign of going away. Anyone watching a Major League Baseball game this past season could hardly miss the likes of Bryce Harper, Christian Yelich, Mike Trout and Giancarlo Stanton sport- ing the extra protection. Those are some pretty strong, unpaid endorse- ments that are doing nothing to get the product approved for use in youth baseball. "It's very gratifying to see the C-Flap being worn by the best players in baseball," says Herb Markwort, president and CEO of Markwort Sporting Goods, who remains frustrated in the lack of official acceptance of C-Flap by youth baseball governing bodies, but remains undaunted in his effort to change minds. The C-Flap is actually a piece of plastic attached to a batting helmet to protect a bat- ter's cheek and jaw. Markwort manufactures and sells the C-Flap, which is then attached to the helmets with three screws. For those who might not know yet, the C-Flap was designed by Dr. Robert Crow, the team doctor for the Atlanta Braves in the early 1980s, in order to protect players who had their jaws wired shut from prior injuries. It was designed to specifically protect the point of the jaw where the wire work was done. So far, so good, except that the C-Flap remains illegal to use at many, if not most, youth levels. Why not? According to Markwort, it's a case of good news and bad news. The good news is that many players and their parents love to buy and install the C-Flap on their batting helmets. The bad news is that when the C-Flap is attached to a batting helmet, the installation can nullify the SEI certification to the NOCSAE standard on the helmet because the original helmet has been altered. In layman's terms, that makes the helmet legally unacceptable. (Note: NOCSAE does not approve or certify any product — it just sets the performance standard. Certifications are now done by SEI.) NOCSAE's overriding concern is that con- sumers will purchase a C-Flap thinking it will give full-face protection, although it does not protect the eye/eye socket, lower jaw and the teeth. As a result, Markwort Sporting Goods has been told that any batting helmet with C-Flap attached needs to be tested and certified from scratch as a new and unique batting helmet. So currently each model of each batting helmet that C-Flap attaches to would technically need to be tested and certified — and every year when new batting helmet models come on the market they would also have to be separately tested with the C-Flap. Markwort says he has countless emails and letters from parents who have expressed their appreciation for access to the C-Flap. And because of the tremendous exposure in recent years at the MLB level, sales of the C-Flap have been at a record pace in the U.S. and Japan and Markwort continues to lobby for a more accepting approval process. Markwort's argument is that since there is no standard for the C-Flap, there is no required testing for it. Any batting helmet with a C–Flap on it that is tested and certified by a NOCSAE/ SEI approved lab and certified by SEI to meet the standard for baseball batter's helmet actually meets the standard, with no additional cost or time requirement than is needed to pass the helmet standard, he maintains. However, the overriding control is with the original equipment manufacturer, (OEM). "The OEM has the choice to accept or not accept any accessory product on its products that are certified by SEI to meet the NOCSAE stan- dard for that product," explains Gregg Hartley, of the Sports & Fitness Industry Association (SFIA), who sits on the NOCSAE board. "If the OEM accepts the accessory product, the origi- nal product is still SEI certified to the NOCSAE standard." Again, NOCSAE does not control the power of approval on any product. And, the approval for use ultimately rests with the governing bodies of each sport. Here even more uncertainty remains. "Our position regarding the C-Flap remains the same," notes Elliot Hopkins, director of sports, sanctioning and student services for National Federation of State High Schools (NFHS). "If the baseball helmet manufacturers approve the addition of products to their helmet, they honor their warranty and it meets the NOCSAE performance standard with it attached, then we would consider allowing the C-Flap." In the meantime, C-Flap remains illegal to use in games sanctioned by the major youth baseball associations ranging from Babe Ruth to Little League to Cal Ripken for one reason — if not certified by NOCSAE, there is no insurance coverage if a player gets hurt wearing a helmet with a C-Flap. Despite these multiple dead-ends, Markwort is willing to cover any potential liability with an insurance policy. "We have product liability insurance that will allow us to not only insure C-Flap but also insure the batting helmets that C-Flap attaches to," he points out. "We can add retailers who want to attach C-Flap to any maker's batting helmet who want assurance that they are covered in case the batting helmet maker says they won't cover their own helmets if C-Flap is attached." AROUND THE BASES A look at issues impacting the game of baseball in 2019. teaminsightmag.com TEAM BASEBALL 18 Team Insight ~ January/February 2019

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of Team Insight - January / February 2019