MDNews - Eastern Pennsylvania/Northwest New Jersey

July/August 2013

Issue link: https://viewer.e-digitaledition.com/i/140434

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 4 of 23

+++++++++++++ +++ Í LEGAL+ +++ LEGAL + +++++++++++++ Corporate Liability Litigation: Not Just for Hospitals Anymore By Stuart T. O'Neal III, Esq. T "cor p or at e liability" in medical malpractice cases continues to evolve, often impacting physicians and other health care providers. A better understanding of what claims these litigations generally involve, along with some proactive measures, may be your best defense for avoiding them in the future. Corporate liability, or institutional malfeasance, has been a staple theory of liability in many medical malpractice cases over the years. As cited in the first hospital case adopting the corporate negligence theory in 1991, Thompson v. Nason Hospital, hospitals have four non-delegable duties to their patients: + To use reasonable care in the maintenance of safe and adequate facilities and equipment; HE THEORY OF + To s e l e c t a n d r e t a i n o n l y competent physicians; + To oversee all persons who practice medicine within their walls as to patient care; and + To formulate, adopt and enforce adequate rules and policies to ensure quality care for patients. Of particular note, the Thompson case held that the failure of a hospital's unidentified employees or agents to report "abnormalities in the treatment and condition of its patients" to the attending physician or hospital authorities created a question of fact. Not only does a hospital have to defend possible corporate negligence based upon the policies, actions or inactions of the institution itself, but it also must separate causes of action relative to specific acts of individual hospital employees, including physicians. In other words, the plaintiff may not be required to establish the identity of someone a llegedly pa rt of the institutional problem but only that an institutional problem existed. A s fa r a s t he element s of corporate liabilit y a re concerned, a plaintiff must plead and prove the hospital deviated from the standard of care, the hospital had actual or constructive notice of the defects or procedures that created the harm, and the hospital's act or omission was a substantial factor in bringing about the harm. Practically speaking, the notice element of a corporate liability claim is one that may come into play when physicia ns a re involved in litigation, whether as individually named defendants or as non-party witnesses. Essentially, it revolves around proving what the physician knew when, about topics ranging f rom pat ient c a re to a n a l lege d equipment malfunction. From a physician perspective, much of what you may be asked about, aside from your particular involvement in clinical care, is what you may or may not have been told by other health care providers regarding changes in condition, test results or lab values, interactions with physicians from other disciplines, and working differentials. Accordingly, documentation confirming any of these conversations and team meetings — especially when collaborating with physicians from different specialties — continues to be essential. Affirmative, proactive documentation repels possible individual involvement in a suit; from a corporate liability perspective, it may also deflect your involvement as a possible weak link in the communication exchange among providers. Other topics individual physicians may be asked about during the course of discovery in institutional claims include the effectiveness or ineffectiveness of hospital equipment and staffing, relations with nurses and patient family members, and adherence to the bevy of hospital policies and procedures. Whenever your hospital is facing a corporate liability suit, whether named as a defendant or not, consulting your hospital's counsel to go over any possible involvement is highly advisable and recommended. Being able to work with him or her to troubleshoot and anticipate possible issues or topics for deposition or trial presentation carries many advantages — both for you and your employer. He a lth c are lit i g ator St u ar t T. O'Neal III is based out of the Philadelphia and Wilkes-Barre offices of Burns White. His practice focuses on the defense of medical facilities, long-term care facilities, and professionals of all types in professional and general liability matters in state court, federal court and at the administrative level. He can be reached at soneal@burnswhite.com. I MDNEWS.COM I MD NEWS Eastern Pennsylvania/NW New Jersey |5

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of MDNews - Eastern Pennsylvania/Northwest New Jersey - July/August 2013