Issue link: https://viewer.e-digitaledition.com/i/140434
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ +++ + +++Í PRACTICE MANAGEMENT+ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Shareholder Disputes in Medical Practices: PREVENTION IS THE BEST MEDICINE By Steven T. Boell Dr. Y: I started the practice with Dr. X a decade ago. He was a great guy, and we got along perfectly. During the past year, he has been unbearable to work with and is "phoning it in." He's clinically incompetent, never shows up for work and is about to get kicked off the medical staff at the hospital. How do I buy him out of the practice? Attorney: To answer that question, I will need to see your shareholders' agreement. Dr. Y: What's a shareholders' agreement? The conversation above is one that a health care attorney too often will have with a client. What actually follows the client's second question is a description of a process in which the client — with limited leverage — is forced to negotiate with an unreasonable partner, followed by a description of the unpredictable, time-consuming and painful process of litigation. Opening a practice generates optimism and excitement. Significant planning is put into facilities, staffing and other day-to-day operations. However, too commonly, a crucial step in the process is omitted: the negotiation of a comprehensive agreement governing the corporate relationship between the co-owners. Typically, for a professional corporation, this takes the form of a shareholders' agreement. In addition to addressing corporate governance, the agreement can answer the following questions: + How will new partners be admitted? Absent an agreed-upon restriction, a partner can freely transfer his or her ownership interest to a third party without the consent of the other owners. Aside from the fact that the ability to approve partners provides peace of mind, in many states there are restrictions on what types of individuals can have an ownership interest in a professional corporation. Certain licenses issued by regulatory agencies (e.g., the Department of Health) require approval if there is a change in ownership. These issues can be addressed in the form of transfer restrictions and/or rights of first refusal. + What happens if a partner dies, becomes disabled or elects to retire? How would the buyout price be set? Will the administrator of his or her estate be reasonable? "Buysell" terms can set forth the process through which a partner's ownership interest can be valued and purchased by the remaining partners. Further, the agreement can protect remaining owners if a partner disengages from the practice without formally retiring. + What happens if your partner loses his or her medical license, loses medical staff privileges or becomes an "excluded provider?" Given the regulatory climate and unique aspects of operating a health care entity, generic documents are not suitable for a medical practice. The agreement must address these and other health care-unique "triggering events." If a partner becomes an excluded provider and refuses to sell his or her ownership interest, it can have a devastating effect on the ability of the practice to obtain certain licenses or accreditations, or to obtain reimbursement from thirdparty payors. + What happens in the event of a deadlock? If a medical practice is owned 50/50 by two physician partners, the agreement must dictate in a reasonable, up-front fashion what occurs in the event of deadlock. Issues such as ownership and access to medical records, noncompetition provisions, and tax planning should be addressed in these agreements. The negotiation of a shareholders' agreement does not necessarily need to be an expensive or contentious process. It is in all the parties' best interests to reach an agreement, as it will provide them with the same level of protection. Negotiating terms in the face of a dispute is impossible, but even for established practices, agreements can be entered into or amended. Steven T. Boell is an attorney in the Healthcare Group at the Center Valley law firm of Fitzpatrick Lentz & Bubba, PC. He regularly represents clients in the health care industry in a variety of transactions and proceedings, including the structuring of joint ventures, administrative law, and compliance with the federal Stark Law and Anti-Kickback Statute. He can be reached at 610-797-9000 and sboell@flblaw.com. I MDNEWS.COM I MD NEWS Eastern Pennsylvania/NW New Jersey | 11

