MDNews - Lower Hudson/Bronx

October 2013

Issue link: https://viewer.e-digitaledition.com/i/184719

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 11 of 39

+++++++++++++++++ + +++ +LEgAL EASE+++ +++++++++++++++++ Prescription — The employmenT lawyer's Examine Arbitration Agreements for Valid Class-Action Waivers By Steven m. Berlin, Esq. E 2001 United States Supreme Court decision in Circuit City Stores, Inc., v. Adams, many employers have been requiring employees to sign agreements to arbitrate employment claims. The Circuit City court held that under the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA), properly drafted agreements requiring employees to waive their right to a jury trial and arbitrate statutory discrimination claims, such as Title VII or ADA claims, are enforceable. The question of whether employee arbitration agreements also waiving the right to bring class action claims are enforceable is still not fully resolved. However, at least for the time being, such waivers are valid in New York. Arbitration is a way to settle disputes outside the court system. Employers tend to favor such agreements for a variety of reasons, including that they often provide a quicker resolution, are less expensive and are decided by a trained impartial professional, not a jury. There are trade-offs, however, such as less prehearing discovery, no ability to appeal, and lawsuits by employees challenging the enforceability and scope of their arbitration agreement. In its 2011 AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion decision, the Supreme Court ruled the FAA compels enforcement of an arbitration agreement that also waives the right of the individual to file a class action. Concepcion involved a consumer claim, the value of which was so low it allegedly did not make economic sense for a person to file an individual, as opposed to a class, claim. Employers hoped that Concepcion could be extended to enforce arbitration 12 VER SInCE THE | Lower Hudson/Bronx MD News ■ MDnEWS.COM agreements pursuant to which employees waived the right to file employmentrelated class actions, such as collective actions for wage and hour claims under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act. While the issue has not been fully resolved by the Supreme Court, it seems that for now, at least in New York, the agreements are enforceable. Enforcement of class-action waivers had initially been derailed by two decisions, one issued in 2012 by the National Labor Relations Board in the D.R. Horton case and a 2009 decision by the federal Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit (which includes New York) In re American Express Merchants' litigation (Amex I). In D.R. Horton, the NLRB effectively ruled that despite the FAA's strong policy favoring arbitration agreements, employees covered by the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) — effectively non-supervisory employees in the private workforce — could not waive their right to bring a class action because such waivers violate an employee's right under Section 7 of the NLRA to engage in concerted activity. D.R. Horton did not preclude arbitration of class claims, only waiver of the right to bring such claims on behalf of a class. As of this writing, that decision remains on appeal, but several federal courts that have been asked to apply it have refused to do so. While Amex I was not an employment decision, the 2nd Circuit invalidated an arbitration agreement's class-action waiver because the plaintiffs would incur prohibitive costs if compelled to arbitrate individually. In early 2013, the Supreme Court reversed that decision in American Express Co. v. Italian Colors Restaurant (Amex/Italian Colors). Relying on its Concepcion decision, the court held that the right to pursue that remedy is not necessarily eliminated just because it may not be worth the expense to prove a remedy on an individual basis. In Sutherland v. Ernst & Young LLP, the 2nd Circuit was faced with the question of the enforceability of an employee's class-action waiver in an arbitration agreement. In its August 2013 decision, the 2nd Circuit both declined to follow D.R. Horton and applied Amex/Italian Colors. The court held that the employee's claim for unpaid overtime wages had to be arbitrated and only on an individual basis. Specifically, the court held that the employee's class-action waiver is not rendered invalid by virtue of the fact that the claim is not economically worth pursuing individually. So what is the employment lawyer's prescription? Employers, whether a small medical practice or a larger healthcare institution, should strongly consider requiring employees to sign arbitration agreements that also waive their right to bring class-action claims. Employers that already have arbitration agreements should review those agreements to make sure class-action waivers are included. When designing or updating arbitration agreements, talk to counsel to be sure the agreements cover the needs of the organization and have the best chance of withstanding a legal challenge. Steven M. Berlin, head of Martin Clearwater & Bell LLP's Employment and Labor Practice Group, is an experienced litigator who has represented clients in a wide range of employment law matters for more than 25 years. For more information, please visit www.mcblaw.com. ■

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of MDNews - Lower Hudson/Bronx - October 2013