Global Down Syndrome

Fall 2014

Issue link: https://viewer.e-digitaledition.com/i/394279

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 13 of 31

FALL2014 DOWN SYNDROME WORLD 14 WELCOME TO POINT/ COUNTERPOINT. Each issue, key representatives from the Down syndrome community will address two sides of an important yet controversial issue. Down Syndrome World is not taking a stand on these issues but rather presenting information so our readers can further investigate and come to their own conclusions. We are fortunate to have two esteemed speech- language pathologists weigh in on the issue. They have written independently of each other, and we thank them for their time and opinions. CON Jennifer Meyers Bekins, M.S., CCC-SLP, is the lead speech-language pathologist at the nationally recognized Jane and Richard Thomas Center for Down Syndrome at Cincinnati Children's Hospital. Parents of children with Down syndrome are often concerned with the development of speech. While oral motor therapies such as Talk Tools are marketed aggressively to families, many professionals have doubts about these methods, and research studies have concluded that nonspeech activities are ineffective for the improvement of speech. There are two reasons to question the effectiveness of OMT. First, research has shown that speech disorders are unrelated to weak muscle tone, due to the minimal amount of strength required to produce speech sounds. Second, speech is a complex process that also involves cognition and language. Not only does OMT isolate muscle movement from these other components, but the movements targeted by the exercises are unrelated to speech and are controlled by different parts of the brain. OMT provides a "one size fits all" method that appeals to parents — there's a sense of accomplishment as the child proceeds from one tool or exercise to the next. It is important to recognize, however, that there is a wide variety of speech disorders, and each has its own set of treatment methods. Families should work with their speech therapist to develop a plan that focuses on their child's speech needs. Meyers Bekins writes a popular blog at talk-ds.org. She has no financial disclosures. Additional resources: Parent-Friendly Information about Non Speech Oral Motor Exercises. Watson & Lof, 2011. DO ORAL MOTOR THERAPIES (OMT), SUCH AS TALK TOOLS, IMPROVE SPEECH OR FEEDING IN CHILDREN WITH DOWN SYNDROME? Point/Counterpoint PRO Allison Magaña, M.S., CCC-SLP, is a speech- language pathologist with Hands On Communication in Denver. Why oral motor placement therapy (OMPT)? Simply because it works. Sara Rosenfeld-Johnson, the founder of Talk Tools, developed a sensorimotor, systematic, evidence-based therapeutic approach to developing safe feeding and speech clarity for children with Down syndrome. OMPT was designed to accompany other therapies to help with clear speech, and it specifically targets jaw stability, lip rounding and retraction, tongue retraction and lateralizing, and breath support. Children with Down syndrome greatly benefit from the additional emphasis on their oral-motor muscles. This approach builds awareness of the muscles of the mouth and then provides activities and exercises, in a hierarchical manner, to target muscle weakness, help organize sensory information, and help coordinate the muscle movements to produce clear speech. Parents have consistently shared how the exercises make sense and are very helpful and manageable. They were designed to help children from birth, first with feeding skills, then with the imitation of simple sounds to eventually linking words to make phrases and sentences. This therapy approach is clear. This therapy approach is effective. This therapy approach works. Magaña can be reached at almagana@comcast.net. Additional resources: talktools.com.

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of Global Down Syndrome - Fall 2014