Global Down Syndrome

Spring 2015

Issue link: https://viewer.e-digitaledition.com/i/518721

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 13 of 31

SPRING2015 DOWN SYNDROME WORLD 14 WELCOME TO POINT/ COUNTERPOINT. Each issue, key representatives from the Down syndrome community will address two sides of an important yet controversial issue. Down Syndrome World is not taking a stand on these issues but rather presenting information so our readers can further investigate and come to their own conclusions. We are fortunate to have two esteemed experts weigh in on the issue. They have written independently of each other, and we thank them for their time and opinions. CON Julie and Chris Messina are the President and a Director, respectively, of the 321 Foundation, a Massachusetts-based nonprofit focused on advancing innovations in education, cognition, and advocacy for people with Down syndrome. History shows that when prenatal tests for conditions that cannot be treated in the womb are introduced, termination of those pregnancies increases. Down syndrome is no exception. Twenty-five years ago when amniocentesis was the only definitive test for Down syndrome, researchers calculated a 20-percent abortion rate. Over the last two decades, however, as new tests were introduced, the abortion rate skyrocketed. The most recent published study on this reports that between 2006 and 2010, there were about 5,300 babies with Down syndrome born and about 3,100 selective abortions performed in the U.S. annually, concluding that the rate of live births of babies with Down syndrome was approximately 30 percent lower than it would be without prenatal testing. Clearly, advances in prenatal testing since the 1970s have been followed by increased selective abortions for Down syndrome. In 2011, noninvasive prenatal screening tests for Down syndrome were introduced. These are deeply troubling, as we can only expect further increases in the abortion rate. While we know that some parents legitimately use prenatal testing to prepare, the stark reality is that it is usually used to detect, then abort, pregnancies testing positive for an extra 21st chromosome. Such prenatal tests move us closer to eliminating entire subpopulations. Every individual has unique value, no matter what his or her capabilities. We declined prenatal testing for Down syndrome in both of our pregnancies because there was nothing positive we could do about the results. Although we were initially devastated when our son was diagnosed with Down syndrome at birth, we soon learned to appreciate his many gifts. Evan has an unparalleled joie de vivre — an attitude from which we could all learn. He also has taught us that imperfection is what makes us all human. Such a lesson, no prenatal test can predict. Learn more at 321foundation.org. SHOULD PREGNANT WOMEN UNDERGO PRENATAL TESTING TO SCREEN FOR OR DIAGNOSE DOWN SYNDROME IN THEIR BABIES? Point/Counterpoint PRO Campbell Brasington, M.S., C.G.C., is a board-certified pediatric genetic counselor at Levine Children's Hospital in Charlotte, North Carolina. She also serves on the Board of Directors of the Down Syndrome Association of Greater Charlotte. No subject seems to generate more emotion and controversy in the Down syndrome community than prenatal testing. Yet each person's attitudes and opinions about testing are informed by a unique set of values, beliefs, and experiences. There is no single "right answer" for which option to choose, as that answer may differ from person to person. Some couples feel strongly that no testing is needed during their pregnancy at all. Others feel they need additional information or perhaps reassurance from a negative result, or they wish to know about a Down syndrome diagnosis prior to delivery. One misconception about prenatal testing is that willingness to test equals willingness to abort. While that is certainly one possible outcome after a positive diagnosis, many couples find it helpful to learn their baby's diagnosis as early as possible, because once the initial shock of the diagnosis has passed, they can move on to learning more about Down syndrome in preparation for their baby's arrival. A baby's delivery can then be a time of celebration, rather than a time filled with questions about the diagnosis. Other parents may choose to create an adoption plan. Because newborn babies with Down syndrome also have an increased chance for certain medical complications, notably heart defects, digestive blockages, and blood disorders that may require transfer to a medical center equipped to manage those conditions, a prenatal diagnosis may help parents choose the best place to deliver their baby. Testing can be powerful if it allows families to make informed decisions that are right for them.

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of Global Down Syndrome - Spring 2015