Global Down Syndrome

Summer 2015

Issue link: https://viewer.e-digitaledition.com/i/545673

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 13 of 31

SUMMER2015 DOWN SYNDROME WORLD 14 WELCOME TO POINT/ COUNTERPOINT. Each issue, key representatives from the Down syndrome community will address two sides of an important yet controversial issue. Down Syndrome World is not taking a stand on these issues but rather presenting information so our readers can further investigate and come to their own conclusions. We are fortunate to have two esteemed experts weigh in on the issue. They have written independently of each other, and we thank them for their time and opinions. CON Ronda Schelvan, M.S.Ed. is a special education teacher from Vancouver, Washington, and co-author of The Hidden Curriculum: Practical Solutions for Understanding Unstated Rules in Social Situations. Inclusion of students with special needs means different things to different people. From my experience, successful inclusion depends largely upon two things: first, a teacher's belief in his or her ability to provide varying levels of support to all students across curricula while building and maintaining a positive sense of classroom and school community, and second, the backing and support of school and district personnel, including financial resources. However, a school offering a "total inclusion" model often falls short of the two criteria mentioned above. In these schools, students are, in fact, placed into same-age peer classrooms but with little preplanning as to the students' strengths, depth of academic challenges, and social and behavioral needs. The result is that the student with special needs is routinely overlooked or — the other extreme — becomes a cherished class mascot. In this situation, the purpose of pullout services, in which children work in separate classrooms with a therapist or special educator, is to supplement rather than supplant their learning. Although students are being taken out of their classroom for specific amounts of time, an effective pullout model is not a way to "dump" students into a special education class. Pullout services should be based on a student's needs, thoughtfully scheduled with the regular education teacher in regards to what is being instructed and is set up to allow students to learn skills they need to access the general education curriculum. They provide opportunity for extra processing time, sensory breaks, or time for one-on-one or small-group instruction. The goal of an effective pullout model is to give students the extra support necessary to build skills they need to lead productive, purposeful lives. Schelvan can be reached at consultforasd@gmail.com. ARE FULL INCLUSION SETTINGS OR PULLOUT SERVICES BETTER FOR STUDENTS WITH DOWN SYNDROME? Point/Counterpoint PRO Patti McVay, M.S.Ed., is Co-Executive Director of Down Syndrome Unites — Championing All Disabilities, an organization that works with schools, students, and families to develop educational plans and resources for students with Down syndrome. It is important to remember that inclusion is about the right of children with disabilities to access their local public schools and expect the same excellence, respect, and sense of belonging to their communities as their typical peers. This right in the United States is embodied in the 1975 Individuals With Disabilities Education Act. The theory and results of inclusion are simple — children with disabilities must and can learn from their typical peers, they can gain academically, and typical peers benefit from having students with disabilities in the classroom. More recently, the best practices of inclusion in the U.S. have moved from partial inclusion (often still inappropriately called "mainstreaming") to full inclusion. Good teachers and good schools, with the proper tools, can and do achieve full inclusion. They have small breakout groups, and therapists provide assistance with curriculum accommodations and modifications — all in the same classroom. Researched best practice tells us when general education teachers take ownership and use tools and strategies in their classrooms that work for students with disabilities, all children benefit because the education of every child can be supported. But educators need training in order to do this! In my training at hundreds of schools, the result is a reduction in referrals to contained special education classrooms. In addition, the general and special educators have confidence to share the responsibility of teaching all students, and there is an eventual decline or elimination of "pullout" services. Parents, educators, and experts need to do more to promote and receive fully inclusive best practices in their schools. We know this will allow students with Down syndrome, and all students, to reach their full potential. McVay can be reached at dsjoy28@gmail.com.

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of Global Down Syndrome - Summer 2015