MDNews - Eastern Pennsylvania/Northwest New Jersey

March/April 2012

Issue link: https://viewer.e-digitaledition.com/i/56098

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 9 of 23

++++++++++++ + + ++++++++++++ LEGAL +++ +++ Susan A. Royster, Esq. Supreme Court to Review Health Care Reform as the 2012 Presidential Election Gears Up ON NOV. 14, 2011, the Un i t e d St a t e s Supreme Cour t announced that it would review challenges to President Barack Obama's signature legislation, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act ("Affordable Care Act" or "the Act"). Immediately following the Act's passage on March 23, 2010, state attorneys gen- eral and other plaintiffs initiated litigation throughout the country seeking judicial review of specific provisions of the Act as well as the constitutional validity of the Act in its entirety. The flurry of litigation over the past two years has left the courts divided. As a result, on March 26, 2012, and within days of the Act's two-year anniversary, the Supreme Court will hear oral arguments on various legal questions related to the Act. By June, the Court is expected to issue its decisions, which may not only determine the viability of the Affordable Care Act, but will likely play a significant role in the hotly contested presidential election. Of the various legal theories pre- sented, the justices will consider, among other issues, the constitutionality of the "individual mandate." Beginning in 2014, the individual mandate will require nearly all uninsured individuals to purchase certain minimum health insurance coverage or pay a federal tax penalty. The constitutionality of the individual mandate has been challenged by, among others, 26 states ("the states"), including Pennsylvania.1 Specifically, the states argue that, among other potential issues, Congress exceeded its power under the Commerce Clause by penalizing an individual for fail- ing to engage in commerce. In addition, the states seek to invalidate the penalty as an improper exercise by Congress of its taxing power. Should the Supreme Court invalidate the individual mandate, the states contend that the entire Act should fall with it. While the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit agreed with the states that Congress exceeded its regulatory power, the court also held that the individual mandate was severable from the remainder of the Act. In response, the United States Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), among others ("the government")2 , argues that Congress appropriately exercised its authority to regulate the health insurance market, asserting that Congress not only main- tained a rational basis for its decision, but also that the decision was necessary and proper. As to the tax penalty, the government maintains that Congress acted properly because, irrespective of the term "penalty" or its regulatory effect, Congress may tax to produce revenue. While the individual mandate is not the only contested provision of the Affordable Care Act, an adverse decision by the Supreme Court could expose the entire Act to a similar fate.3 Accordingly, the outcome of the Supreme Court's review will not only play an important role in guiding the health care industry as to the Act's applicability, but, in the short term, will likely become a heated source of debate this summer as the Republican candidate and the president, along with their parties, battle it out during this contentious election year. 1 The states involved are Iowa, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Kansas, Louisiana, Maine, Mississippi, Nebraska, Nevada, North Dakota, Ohio, South Carolina, South Dakota, Texas, Utah, Washington, Wisconsin and Wyoming. 2 In addition to HHS, the Departments of the Treasury and Labor, as well as their respec- tive secretaries, are named on behalf of the federal government. 3 While Congress' ability to regulate has been a focal point of legal argument, the Supreme Court could focus on another issue raised in which it could hold that the individual mandate cannot be challenged until imposed in 2014. ■ 10 | Eastern Pennsylvania/NW New Jersey MD NEWS ■ MDNEWS.COM

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of MDNews - Eastern Pennsylvania/Northwest New Jersey - March/April 2012