Global Down Syndrome

Fall 2015

Issue link: https://viewer.e-digitaledition.com/i/618504

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 17 of 31

THE SPECIAL OLYMPICS AND THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF PEDIATRICS AGREE: IF HEALTHY, LET THEM PLAY. ATLANTOAXIAL INSTABILITY: No Longer a Game-Breaker? AT AGE 17, Brianna Cordova is old enough to have had several screening X-rays for atlantoaxial instability (AAI), which about 15 percent of people with Down syndrome have. She's also old enough to do back handsprings off of balance beams in her hometown of Parker, Colorado. Brianna's a cheerleader, too, and it's easy for her Legend High School teammates to hoist her four- foot-seven, roughly 80-pound frame into the air for stunts. That's all fine with Brianna's mom, Heather Cordova. Those X-rays to look for AAI — a condition in which loose ligaments cause slippage between the first and second cervical vertebrae (the atlantoaxial joint) that can cause spinal-cord damage and a host of neurological problems — were taken when Brianna was an infant and then again when she was in middle school so she could compete in the Special Olympics. In Brianna's case, they always came back negative. But it turns out that those AAI screening X-rays did little to predict the risk to Brianna's neck. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and the Special Olympics have independently concluded that screening X-rays don't correlate with injury risk, and that those with Down syndrome who are otherwise healthy can and should play without letting the results of an AAI screening X-ray get in the way. This is not to discount the seriousness of symptomatic AAI. If a medical exam finds that AAI is causing neurological problems such as tiredness, walking difficulties, neck pain, head tilt, clumsiness, sensory deficits, and other symptoms (the Special Olympics says about 1.5 percent of athletes with Down syndrome show such signs), sports should cease, as there's a risk of "imminent spinal cord injury." The abandonment of the diagnostic X-ray represents a sea change in the approach to AAI, said Matt Holder, M.D., M.B.A., C.E.O. of the Lee Specialty Clinic in Louisville, Kentucky, and the Special Olympics' global medical advisor. AAP guidelines issued in 1984 said X-rays should be done for all children with Down syndrome, and that, if a gap between the first and second vertebra were greater than 4.5 millimeters, sports should be restricted. This was, Dr. Holder said, "what they thought would be the best and most cautious plan." That plan would stay in place, more or less, for nearly 30 years. It stopped countless kids with X-ray-diagnosed AAI from doing a long list of events, among them artistic gymnastics, soccer, alpine skiing, diving, and high jump. But the data kept coming in, and in the mid-2000s, Dr. Holder and others consulted medical organizations and orthopedic experts, and reviewed some 300 articles related to AAI. Evidence from a subset of those with Down syndrome, AAI, and a spinal-cord injury associated with sports participation was "really tough" to find, he said. At the same time, Marilyn Bull, M.D., F.A.A.P., Professor of Pediatrics, Developmental Pediatrics at Riley Hospital for Children at Indiana University Health, was leading the team creating the AAP's clinical report, "Health Supervision for Children With Down Syndrome." X-rays, she and colleagues concluded, "are not predictive" of AAI- associated injury risk. "Thousands of kids were unnecessarily restricted from physical activity," Dr. Bull said. Her report was published in 2011; she hasn't ordered an AAI X-ray since. In 2014, the Special Olympics' guidelines were updated based on Holder's team's advice. The gist of both: don't sweat the screening X-ray, and if there aren't neurological symptoms of AAI, let them play — within limits, of course. Dr. Bull said she would avoid activities like heading soccer balls and playing tackle football — and in particular using trampolines. But she advises the same for kids without Down syndrome, too. The prominent physical therapist and author Patricia Winders, P.T., Director of Therapies and Senior Physical Therapist at the Anna and John J. Sie Center for Down Syndrome, recommends parents simply be aware that the necks of kids with Down syndrome may be less stable and that protecting the neck should be a priority. She advises against somersaults, for example. "Anything that's going to cause undue stress on the neck, you just want to stay away from," Winders said. Brianna Cordova hasn't quite heeded that advice, having started tumbling at age 3. "I do not restrict her," her mom, Heather, said. "Kids should be able to be all they can be, and sometimes that 'be all you can be' is in sports." FALL2015 DOWN SYNDROME WORLD 18

Articles in this issue

Archives of this issue

view archives of Global Down Syndrome - Fall 2015