MDNews - Lower Hudson/Bronx

July 2012

Issue link: https://viewer.e-digitaledition.com/i/71820

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 13 of 23

++++++++++++++++++ + + ++++++++++++++++++ LEGAL EASE +++ +++ An Employment Lawyer's Prescription: Patient Safety and Employee Prescription Drug Use By Steven M. Berlin and John G. Zeitler IN ADDITION TO PATIENTS, medical professionals and their staff may also be taking prescription drugs. Health care employers must be cog- nizant of their employees' rights with regard to prescription drugs and the extent to which such medications can impact job performance, particularly where patient health is concerned. Like anyone else, health care employ- ees have the right to use prescription medications without being discrimi- nated against under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and the New York Human Rights Law. An employer cannot terminate, demote or take any other adverse action on the basis of an actual (or even perceived) impairment, provided the employee can perform essential job functions with or without a reasonable accommodation. Allowing employees to medicate on the job is one such accommodation. Suppose an ICU nurse suffers from a back injury and takes an opiate analgesic for the pain. She has a right not to be discriminated against on the basis of her condition, even if the injury or the effects of the medication prevent her from performing some of her duties — that is, so long as she can continue to perform essential job functions, even if the hospital has to provide a reasonable accommodation. The accommodation could include reducing or shifting her assigned tasks. It could also include allowing her to take pain medication or re-arranging her work schedule to coincide with her medication schedule. Likewise, a physician with a mental con- dition has a right to medicate without adverse action from his employer and is entitled to an accommodation that does not put a significant strain on the employer's resources. But what if prescription drug use poses a threat to patient safety? According to the New York State Office of Alcoholism and Substance Abuse Services, between 1991 and 2009, New York state experienced a fourfold increase in prescriptions for opioid analgesics to nearly 180 million. Recognizing that individuals in the medical community also rely on medications that can affect cognitive function, these increases pose a potentially serious threat to patient safety. Fortunately, Equal Employment Opportunity Commission regulations permit employers to take measures to ensure employees do not pose a direct threat to the health and safety of any individual in the workplace. Similarly, under the ADA, employers can require medical examinations or inquire into an employee's disability if the inquiry or examination is job related and consistent with business necessity. Because patient safety is both an inherent concern and a business necessity of medical organizations, health care employers have somewhat greater flexibility in taking action to address disabilities that pose a threat to health or safety. Although employees generally cannot be asked about their prescription drug use, employers can question employees, such as the ICU nurse in the previous example, whose inability or impaired ability to perform essential job functions poses a direct threat. Additionally, an employer can investigate any employee he or she reasonably believes is physically or chemically impaired. The employer may question the employee or cowork- ers, require diagnostic or toxicology testing, or even insist the employee sub- mit to a physical examination. However, before taking any adverse action based on a real or perceived impairment, it is critical that employers engage in an interactive process that considers the circumstances of the individual employee in an effort to accommodate the specific disability. Employers should also establish a clear policy explaining which drugs employees may be tested for and under what circumstances. So, what is the employment lawyer's prescription? While health care employ- ers enjoy some flexibility in addressing job performance issues related to pre- scription drug use, they must balance their concern for patient safety with the rights of employees to medicate on the job without discrimination and engage in a process that accommodates those disabilities on an individual basis. Steven M. Berlin is head of Martin Clearwater & Bell LLP's Employment and Labor Practice Group. John G. Zeitler is a senior associate with the firm. ■ 14 | Lower Hudson/Bronx MD NEWS ■ MDNEWS.COM

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of MDNews - Lower Hudson/Bronx - July 2012